People keep telling me to just sign a new contract with another provider and get a subsidized phone; they hear the price of the phone I'm going to buy and act like I'm crazy. I want to run the numbers hear to show why everyone saying that... is crazy.
I want to buy a Google phone for my Sprint plan, without dropping my actual plan because my Sprint plan is so low in price ($30/mo).
I want a strong Android phone with a keyboard. My plan has 450 minutes, infinite text, and infinite data, which I'm happy with. Let's take some common price points as examples.
* iPhone: Let's pretend I wanted an iPhone - it's the #1 phone by far for a reason. I hate its lack of a keyboard, but let's pretend. $100 for the phone (subsidized), $90/mo to AT&T on a 2-year contract, with taxes and fees call it $115. AppleCare from Apple is another $69 to protect the phone. AT&T's coverage lately is notoriously crap for the iPhone, so there's a suffering built-in here.
iPhone & AT&T: $100 + $70 + $115*24 = $170 + $2760 = $2930.
* Expensive plan: Verizon will sell me a Droid for $200 if I sign a 2-year contract. The lowest I can go on that plan is 450 minutes with infinite data and infinite texts (nights start at 9pm) for $100/mo before taxes and fees. With taxes and fees that's about $130/mo. Since that 2-year contract is really subsidizing that phone, let's do the math:
Verizon and Droid: $200 + $130*24 = $200 + $3120 = $3320.
* My plan, retail phone: My current plan on Sprint is only $30/mo, $35/mo after taxes and fees, for the same service Verizon is providing. There are some caveats: Sprint coverage is comparable but Verizon works in the subway. Sprint rents time on Verizon's network and failovers between the 2 mid-call can be noticable. But generally the signal is good. Sprint's customer service is terrible - you really couldn't do worse than Sprint when it comes to calling someone to get something solved, unless that company you're calling is Google (they don't even give you a phone number... at least Sprint lets you call so a recording can hang up on you).
If I stick with my current plan, which is only $30/mo for the same service Verizon is providing above, I need to buy a new phone full price (on Sprint that's a Samsung Moment). Best Buy will sell me one for $650, and if I get the Extended Warranty it's another $170 - if anything happens to it I can get it replaced for free.
Sprint and Best Buy: $650 + $170 + $35*24 = $820 + $840 = $1660.
* My plan, online retailer, local repair company: If I just search for the Samsung Moment online, I get this mess. But if I force the name to be in the title and look for things over $150, I get this tidy search. That includes an online retailer with GREAT reviews selling for $370 - which just goes to show how much Best Buy is making off of you (and Sprint when they sell it to you at $475).
But an online retailer isn't going to service my phone. A local provider, CellularDr, will fix most basic issues like broken keys or a broken screen for parts and labor - judging from their website about $100 a fix, total. Let's say I break it twice in 2 years - reasonable assumption:
Sprint, online retailer, Cellular Dr: $370 + $200 + $35*24 = $570 + $840 = $1410.
So as you can see, if I decided to go to Verizon with a Droid, I'd get slightly better coverage, somewhat better customer service, and probably replace broken phones for a reasonable fee here and there at the Verizon store (maybe another $100 on top of that).
If I decide to buy my phone outright, I'm not even on a contract - I can change phones or drop service any time without a fee - and I save $3320-1410 = $1910.
So yes, I am going to buy my phone outright, because I like keeping my $2000.
I want to buy a Google phone for my Sprint plan, without dropping my actual plan because my Sprint plan is so low in price ($30/mo).
I want a strong Android phone with a keyboard. My plan has 450 minutes, infinite text, and infinite data, which I'm happy with. Let's take some common price points as examples.
* iPhone: Let's pretend I wanted an iPhone - it's the #1 phone by far for a reason. I hate its lack of a keyboard, but let's pretend. $100 for the phone (subsidized), $90/mo to AT&T on a 2-year contract, with taxes and fees call it $115. AppleCare from Apple is another $69 to protect the phone. AT&T's coverage lately is notoriously crap for the iPhone, so there's a suffering built-in here.
iPhone & AT&T: $100 + $70 + $115*24 = $170 + $2760 = $2930.
* Expensive plan: Verizon will sell me a Droid for $200 if I sign a 2-year contract. The lowest I can go on that plan is 450 minutes with infinite data and infinite texts (nights start at 9pm) for $100/mo before taxes and fees. With taxes and fees that's about $130/mo. Since that 2-year contract is really subsidizing that phone, let's do the math:
Verizon and Droid: $200 + $130*24 = $200 + $3120 = $3320.
* My plan, retail phone: My current plan on Sprint is only $30/mo, $35/mo after taxes and fees, for the same service Verizon is providing. There are some caveats: Sprint coverage is comparable but Verizon works in the subway. Sprint rents time on Verizon's network and failovers between the 2 mid-call can be noticable. But generally the signal is good. Sprint's customer service is terrible - you really couldn't do worse than Sprint when it comes to calling someone to get something solved, unless that company you're calling is Google (they don't even give you a phone number... at least Sprint lets you call so a recording can hang up on you).
If I stick with my current plan, which is only $30/mo for the same service Verizon is providing above, I need to buy a new phone full price (on Sprint that's a Samsung Moment). Best Buy will sell me one for $650, and if I get the Extended Warranty it's another $170 - if anything happens to it I can get it replaced for free.
Sprint and Best Buy: $650 + $170 + $35*24 = $820 + $840 = $1660.
* My plan, online retailer, local repair company: If I just search for the Samsung Moment online, I get this mess. But if I force the name to be in the title and look for things over $150, I get this tidy search. That includes an online retailer with GREAT reviews selling for $370 - which just goes to show how much Best Buy is making off of you (and Sprint when they sell it to you at $475).
But an online retailer isn't going to service my phone. A local provider, CellularDr, will fix most basic issues like broken keys or a broken screen for parts and labor - judging from their website about $100 a fix, total. Let's say I break it twice in 2 years - reasonable assumption:
Sprint, online retailer, Cellular Dr: $370 + $200 + $35*24 = $570 + $840 = $1410.
So as you can see, if I decided to go to Verizon with a Droid, I'd get slightly better coverage, somewhat better customer service, and probably replace broken phones for a reasonable fee here and there at the Verizon store (maybe another $100 on top of that).
If I decide to buy my phone outright, I'm not even on a contract - I can change phones or drop service any time without a fee - and I save $3320-1410 = $1910.
So yes, I am going to buy my phone outright, because I like keeping my $2000.
Leave a comment